-
When this checklist applies
-
Step 1: Define the actual use case before you open a catalog
-
Step 2: Verify the vendor can invoice you properly—before you order anything
-
Step 3: Request the actual spec sheet—not the sales brochure
-
Step 4: Price the total cost of ownership, not the sticker price
-
Step 5: Test the product in a real setting before you commit to volume
-
Step 6: Confirm lead times—and have a backup plan
-
Step 7: Document the decision—even the messy parts
-
What I'd watch out for
When this checklist applies
If you're the one handling facility purchasing for a multi-building company—elevator service contracts, bathroom supplies, cleaning products, storage rentals—this is for you. I'm the office administrator for a 280-person company across two buildings. I manage roughly $340K in annual facility spending. That covers elevator maintenance, cleaning contracts, bathroom fixtures, storage rentals, and the occasional oddball purchase like a frameless shower door for the employee gym.
I've been doing this since 2020. The checklist below is what I run before I sign any new vendor contract. Seven steps. Takes about 90 minutes. It's saved me from repeating the $2,400 invoice mistake I made in my first year.
One thing before we start: the stuff you buy for your building isn't just operational. It's a signal. The elevator buttons in your lobby, the streaks on your conference room windows, the shower door in the gym—visitors notice these. They read as a reflection of how your company operates. I've had client feedback meetings where someone mentioned the bathroom fixtures. That stuck with me.
Step 1: Define the actual use case before you open a catalog
Most purchasing mistakes happen here. You see a product page, the specs look fine, the price is right, and you order. Three weeks later you realize the thing doesn't fit your actual situation.
The fix is boring but effective: write down who uses it, where, and how often. A thyssenkrupp elevator button panel for a high-traffic lobby in a 12-story building is a different animal from the same product in a 3-person satellite office. Same brand, same category—wildly different wear expectations.
I learned this the hard way with a frameless shower door we ordered for the employee gym in 2022. I checked the dimensions, confirmed the glass thickness, and placed the order. What I didn't check was whether the hinges could handle daily use by 280 people. They couldn't. Not the ones we bought, anyway. We replaced the hardware within six months.
Checkpoint: Write one sentence describing the use case. If you can't, you're not ready to buy.
Step 2: Verify the vendor can invoice you properly—before you order anything
This is the step most people skip. I know because I was one of them.
In 2021, I found a great price on glass cleaner from a new supplier. We go through the stuff constantly, and the savings looked meaningful. I ordered a six-month supply. The product was fine. The invoice was handwritten. Finance rejected the expense report flat out. I ate $2,400 out of the department budget.
Now I verify invoicing before I place any order. Three questions:
- Can you provide a proper itemized invoice with your tax ID?
- Do you accept our standard payment terms, or do you need prepayment?
- Who do I contact if the invoice gets rejected?
If a vendor hesitates on any of these, I walk. No exceptions.
Step 3: Request the actual spec sheet—not the sales brochure
Sales brochures are marketing. Spec sheets are engineering. You want the latter.
When we needed to replace the hardware on the thyssenkrupp home elevator swing door in our executive guest house—yes, that's a real thing I had to deal with—the first vendor sent a glossy PDF full of lifestyle photos. Pretty. Useless. The second vendor sent a two-page spec sheet with load ratings, cycle counts, and a clear installation diagram. That's the one we went with.
Per FTC advertising guidelines, vendors are supposed to substantiate their product claims (ftc.gov/business-guidance/advertising-marketing). But "supposed to" and "did" aren't the same thing. Asking for the spec sheet is your filter.
Checkpoint: Can you find the actual dimensions, materials, and operating limits on paper? If not, keep asking.
Step 4: Price the total cost of ownership, not the sticker price
This is where a lot of admin buyers get burned. The sticker price is the easy number. The real number includes delivery, installation, maintenance, and disposal.
Take storage. When we needed overflow space for seasonal decorations and event supplies, I asked the obvious question: how much is a storage unit? The first answer was $180 a month. Fine. But that didn't include the admin fee, the lock, the insurance requirement, or the fact that the unit was on the fourth floor with no loading dock. The real monthly cost was closer to $260.
Same logic applies to elevators. A thyssenkrupp maintenance contract looks different when you factor in response-time guarantees and parts availability. The cheapest monthly rate often comes with the longest wait when something breaks.
Checkpoint: List every cost you'll pay over 12 months. Not just the first invoice.
Step 5: Test the product in a real setting before you commit to volume
This sounds obvious. It's not, because most vendors want you to commit to a volume order before they'll send a sample.
For consumables like glass cleaner, I ask for a single case first. We test it on the actual glass in our lobby—the stuff that gets smudged by 280 people a day. Some cleaners streak after two days. Some are fine. You can't tell from the label.
For equipment, I ask for a trial period. When we evaluated a new elevator button panel for the main lobby, we ran a 30-day trial on one floor before committing to the full building. The buttons held up fine. The display, however, was too dim in direct sunlight. We wouldn't have known that from a showroom demo.
This is also where the quality-perception thing comes in. The difference between a $12 glass cleaner and an $8 one is roughly $4. The difference between a clean glass wall and a streaky one is what your clients see when they walk in. I'm not saying always buy the expensive option. I'm saying price the impression, not just the bottle.
Step 6: Confirm lead times—and have a backup plan
Lead times are where "good price" meets "bad timing."
I don't have hard data on how often commercial elevator parts arrive late, but based on our last four years of orders, my sense is that 15–20% of custom or specialty items run past the quoted date. That's not a scientific estimate—just what I've seen.
For anything that affects building operations (elevator components, bathroom fixtures, storage access), I ask two questions:
- What's the realistic lead time, not the best-case one?
- If it arrives late, what's the backup?
If the vendor can't answer the second question, I assume there is no backup. And I plan accordingly.
Step 7: Document the decision—even the messy parts
This is the step that feels like a waste of time until it saves you.
Write down why you chose this vendor over the other two. What did you pay? What did you give up? What did the vendor promise, and what did they put in writing?
I keep a simple spreadsheet: date, vendor, product, quoted price, actual price, lead time, and a one-line note on why we went this direction. It's not elegant. But when finance asks why we're paying 12% more than last year, I can show them—not guess.
What I'd watch out for
Don't let the catalog set your specs. Decide what you need first, then find the product that matches. Not the other way around.
Premium doesn't always mean better. I've overpaid for brand names that performed worse than mid-range alternatives. The checklist helps—but it's not a guarantee.
Relationships matter, but so does paperwork. A vendor who returns your calls but can't send a clean invoice is still a problem. Both things can be true.
This pricing was accurate as of Q4 2024. Facility costs move. Verify current rates before you budget.